AMFS NL Logo
 
Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy (AKA Complex Regional Pain Syndrome)
Counselor,

Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy or Complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) may develop as a disproportionate consequence of a trauma affecting the limbs without nerve injury (CRPS I or reflex sympathetic dystrophy [RSD]) or with obvious nerve lesions (CRPS II or causalgia).

CRPS is a relatively common disabling disorder of unknown pathophysiology. RSD is a variable symptom complex that probably results from any number of multiple causes through different pathophysiologic mechanisms. Changes in the peripheral and central somatosensory, autonomic, and motor processing and a pathologic interaction of sympathetic and afferent systems are described as underlying mechanisms.

We value all your comments, so, if you have a suggestion for a newsletter subject but haven't submitted it yet, or if you have already submitted one but think of another, please take a minute to let us know by clicking on your "Reply" button and dropping us a note.

To learn more about AMFS, Inc., the organization run by Physicians and Attorneys that provides medical experts and case review services nationwide, and has produced the following informational newsletter to aid you in understanding complex medical issues, please click here - www.medicalexperts.com.

 

Frequency, Mortality/Morbidity, and Distribution:

In the US: Limited information is available about the epidemiology of CRPS in the United States and internationally. Actual incidence is unknown, as CRPS is often misdiagnosed. Some sources report, the incidence of causalgia (CRPS II) following injury to a peripheral nerve is 1-5%. The incidence of RSD (CRPS I) is 1-2% after various fractures and 2-5% after peripheral nerve injury.

RSD has significant morbidity, so raising awareness of this disease is important. Earlier recognition and appropriate referral is very important, especially in children. Prompt referral can avoid unnecessary investigations and treatments that may worsen the condition.

RSD is reported more commonly in women. In one study, which reviewed of 829 patients, 628 patients were female (76%) and 201 male (24%).

 
 

Clinical History:

The typical clinical picture of CRPS consists of disproportionate extremity pain, swelling, and autonomic (sympathetic) and motor symptoms. The condition can affect the upper or lower extremities, but it is slightly more common in the upper extremities, usually evidenced by:

Pain is reported in more than 90% of patients. Most patients describe worsening of pain or other symptoms after exercising the affected limb.

Vascular abnormalities, often abnormal vasodilation and skin warming in the early phase and vasoconstriction in later stages, are characteristic symptoms of RSD/CRPS I.

Typically, patients with CRPS exhibit a warm and vasodilated affected extremity in the early stages and cold and pale skin in the later stages.

The common physical characteristic features of RSD (CRPS I) are spontaneous pain, hyperalgesia, impairment of motor function, swelling, changes in sweating, and vascular abnormalities in a single extremity. An overt nerve injury is not detectable.

Various sensory symptoms have been observed, including allodynia (mechanical and thermal); hyperalgesia (mechanical and thermal); hyperpathia; hypoesthesia; hypothermesthesia; and proprioception and anesthesia dolorosa (ie, sensibility to touch is absent while severe pain is present in the anesthetic area). On rare occasions, a dissociated sensory pattern may be noted.

Based on the IASP consensus conference, there are 2 types of CRPS, namely CRPS I (RSD) and CRPS II (causalgia). These 2 types are differentiated mainly based upon whether the inciting incident included a definable nerve injury. CRPS I (RSD) - Occurs after initial noxious event other than a nerve injury. CRPS II (causalgia) - Occurs after nerve injury. In most other ways, CRPS I and CRPS II are quite similar. Features common to both CRPS types I and II include the following:

Pain, whether spontaneous or evoked, may include allodynia (painful response to a stimulus that is not usually painful) and/ or hyperalgesia (exaggerated response to a stimulus that is usually only mildly painful). Pain that is disproportionate to the inciting event (eg, years of severe pain after an ankle sprain). Regional pain that is not limited to a single peripheral nerve distribution. Evidence of autonomic dysregulation (eg, edema, alteration in blood flow, hyperhidrosis). Diagnosis is excluded if another condition could account for the degree of pain and dysfunction.

Causes: Various insults that may lead to RSD include the following: Trauma (eg, sprain, dislocations, fractures, surgery, burns, crash injury); Neurologic disorders (eg, stroke, tumor, syringomyelia); Herpes zoster infection; Myocardial infarction; Musculoskeletal disorder (shoulder rotator cuff injury); Malignancy; Spontaneous/idiopathic.

One study reported that, in 65% of cases, RSD followed trauma (mostly a fracture); in 19% of cases, it followed an operation; and in 2% of cases, it followed an inflammatory process. In 4% of cases, onset of symptoms followed various other precipitating factors, such as injection, intravenous infusion, or cerebrovascular accident. In 10% of cases, no precipitant could be identified. CRPS II (causalgia) has been reported after automated laser discectomy and cervical epidural injection.

 

Evaluation and Diagnosis:

No diagnostic lab study criteria have been accepted uniformly for RSD, and no single special investigation has been proven sensitive and specific enough for diagnosing RSD. No criterion standard exists for making this clinical diagnosis, although some tests and findings may contribute to the diagnosis or help to diagnose or exclude other possible medical conditions. As required, routine and specific blood tests and other studies should be performed to identify precipitating causes. The exact tests vary according to the body region involved, as well as to the findings of the history and physical examination.

X-ray films may show patchy periarticular demineralization within 3-6 weeks. The extent of osteoporosis is more than expected from disuse alone, and it is a common abnormality revealed on radiographs.

A 3-phase bone scan may be helpful both in revealing findings typical for the diagnosis of RSD and also in excluding other conditions that could cause the patient's symptoms. A false negative bone scan is fairly common. This scan is often considered sensitive and specific, particularly in the early phase (less than 20 weeks) of the syndrome, but a study by Warner reports that the 3-phase bone scan has shown a diagnostic sensitivity of only 44%.

Scintigraphic abnormalities were reported in up to 60% of RSD patients and may be useful in arriving at the diagnosis of RSD and in predicting which patients are likely to respond to systemic steroid therapy. Abnormal increased activity must be diffuse, not focal.

Other tests include measuring skin temperatures and noting vascular changes. The measurement is simple, but important, to record during examination of the patient with RSD. Skin temperature is measured by (1) tactile perception, (2) surface thermistors, and (3) hand-held infrared thermometers.

There are a host of other complex tests that are beyond the scope of this paper. These include: Sudomotor function testing, sweat test, Quantitative sudomotor axon reflex test (QSART), Chemical sweat test, Electrodiagnostic studies, Diagnostic sympathetic ganglion block and other testing modalities.

 

Rehabilitation Program:

Physical Therapy: A steady progression of gentle weight bearing to progressive active weight bearing is very important in patients with RSD. Gradual desensitization to increasing sensory stimuli also plays an important role. Gradual increase in normalized sensation tends to reset the altered processing in the CNS. Other intervention should be offered to enable greater confidence and comfort when patients do not progress in a reasonable amount of time.

Physical therapy (PT), in association with occupational therapy (OT), plays an important role in functional restoration. The goal is to increase strength and flexibility gradually beginning with gentle gliding exercises. Patients usually are reluctant to participate in PT because of intense pain. A self-directed or therapist-directed PT program is important and should be individualized to each patient's needs and goals.

Patients with CRPS also may have myofascial pain syndrome. Myofascial pain may be treated with modalities and techniques such as massage and myofascial release.

Occupational therapists usually are responsible for introducing and maintaining a stress loading program for patients with CRPS.The stress loading program usually is started as a home exercise program. The patient also can use desensitization techniques (eg, rubbing the skin, massage, tapping, vibration) to reduce sensitivity and pain.

Recreational Therapy: Recreational therapy can help the patient with chronic pain take part in pleasurable activities that help decrease pain.

All treatments should focus primarily on functional restoration. Use of drugs, sympathetic blocks, and psychotherapy helps to achieve good pain control during physical therapy.

Early intervention is important. The key to successful treatment of RSD is recognition of symptoms in stage I or early in stage II. Physicians should be alert for signs and symptoms of RSD. When RSD is suspected, the treating physician should ensure that that the patient receives evaluation by a pain specialist or other clinician experienced in treating this condition.

Surgical Intervention: For the upper extremity, a stellate (cervicothoracic) ganglion block is recommended. Bupivacaine is preferred over lidocaine because of its longer half-life. Not all patients experience pain relief after blocks.

Percutaneous lumbar sympathetic plexus catheter placement usually provides short-term pain relief in most patients and may have some long-term effect.

Bier block (intravenous regional block) has been utilized with some positive results bu the Somatic block, consisting of continuous epidural infusion with different variants of brachial plexus blocks, includes an axillary, supraclavicular, or infraclavicular approach that has been more useful.

Dorsal column stimulators have been used successfully to relieve localized extremity pain. A spinal cord stimulator (SCS) can be an effective treatment for the pain of RSD, including recurrent pain after ablative sympathectomy.

 

Complications of the Disease:

The following can occur as a conseqence of the disease:

Chronic edema (occasionally chronic lymphoedema); Chronic relapsing infections and ulcers resistant to treatment; Brown- grey scaly pigmentations of the skin; Recurrent unexplained spontaneous hematomas; Dystonia, tremor, and other movement disorders; Clubbing of fingers or toes and hourglass nails; Depression and other psychiatric disorders.

 

Medical/Legal Pitfalls & Special Concerns:

Patients with RSD often are labeled psychogenic or malingering if their pain sources are not recognized, which may occur especially in the early stages. Recognition and treatment of RSD at the early stages is very important in order to maximize outcome.

RSD is rare in childhood, but it has significant morbidity. Therefore, awareness of this disease is important, so that children with this condition can be recognized earlier and referred for appropriate treatment. As noted earlier, awareness may avoid unnecessary investigations and treatments that may worsen the condition.

 
 

Since 1990 and through 100,000+ nationwide cases, AMFS, Inc. (American Medical Forensic Specialists) has been providing plaintiff and defense attorneys in-house case evaluations as well as access to a carefully screened, nationwide panel of more than 7,500 board-certified medical experts practicing in all specialties and regions of the country.

With just a single phone call, you reach an in-house staff physician who will assist you in clarifying the medical issues present in your case, identifying the medical specialties involved and interviewing prospective experts from our panel for your case.

Whether you need a physician to review your case, testify as an expert, perform an IME, or perform any other task in the medical-legal field, in any region of the country, AMFS can help. As always, our mission is to provide counsel with the most efficient way to retain quality experts in a timely, cost effective manner.

Call Today to Speak with an AMFS Staff Physician at NO Charge. Or use this handy form to submit a case for a Quick Review.

Thank you for your time,


Attorney & Physician Advisory Board
AMFS, Inc.

CALL TOLL FREE: 1-800-275-8903